Category: Concepts

  • Economic conversion explained: history and tools

    Economic conversion explained: history and tools

    In short: economic conversion, also called defence or arms conversion, is the process of moving resources such as workers, factories and research from military production to civilian markets. It happened on a huge scale after the Second World War, was championed by Columbia engineer Seymour Melman from the 1970s, and was tested by workers’ plans such as Britain’s 1976 Lucas Plan. In the United States the main federal tool has been the Office of Economic Adjustment, founded in 1961 and renamed in 2021.

    The phrase economic conversion turns up in budget fights, union campaigns and state laws, often without a definition. This guide explains what it means, where the idea came from, the main approaches tried, and the arguments for and against. It is written as neutral background for the other explainers on this site, including our guides to Connecticut economic conversion law and military spending and jobs research.

    What is economic conversion?

    Economic conversion is the shift of economic resources from military to civilian uses. Wikipedia’s article on economic conversion describes it as moving labour, capital and technology from defence work into civilian markets, and notes the related terms defence conversion and arms conversion. The word covers both a single factory changing its products and a national policy of shrinking the military sector while protecting jobs.

    Conversion is different from simple budget cuts. A cut reduces spending; conversion is about what happens next to the people and places that depended on that spending. That is why plans usually include retraining, new product development and help for local governments.

    A vintage 1940s factory assembly line with rows of car bodies
    After 1945 American industry reconverted from war production to civilian goods. Illustration.

    Reconversion after the Second World War

    The largest conversion in American history followed 1945, when factories that had built tanks, aircraft and ships returned to making cars, appliances and other consumer goods. The Wikipedia article notes that this process was called reconversion at the time. Interest in conversion revived after the Cold War ended, when defence budgets fell, and then faded from the late 1990s.

    Engineering blueprints spread on a drafting table with a ruler and pencil
    Conversion plans start with what a workforce already knows how to design and build. Illustration.

    Seymour Melman and the conversion movement

    The modern idea of economic conversion is closely tied to Seymour Melman (1917–2004), a professor of industrial engineering and operations research at Columbia University. Wikipedia’s biography of Melman lists his books Pentagon Capitalism (1970) and Profits Without Production among others, and records that he chaired the National Commission for Economic Conversion and Disarmament.

    His Pentagon Capitalism carried the subtitle The Political Economy of War, and the conversion movement he led treated military spending as an economic choice with costs for civilian industry. The idea that defence plants should plan civilian alternatives in advance, through joint committees of employees and employers, appears in Connecticut state law, as our Connecticut guide explains.

    Large wind turbine blades being finished in a factory hall
    Wind turbines appeared among the civilian products proposed in the 1976 Lucas Plan. Illustration.

    The Lucas Plan

    The best-known worker-led conversion proposal came from Britain. In January 1976 shop stewards at Lucas Aerospace, organised as the Lucas Aerospace Combine, published an alternative corporate plan in response to announced job cuts. Wikipedia’s article on the Lucas Plan says it contained more than 150 product designs, including wind turbines, hybrid cars, heat pumps and energy-efficient housing, drawn from the workforce’s own skills.

    Management met the plan with considerable hostility and it was never adopted as company policy. It was nonetheless nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize in 1979, and it is still cited as an example of conversion planning from the shop floor.

    How governments manage defence cutbacks

    In the United States the main federal tool has been a Pentagon office rather than a conversion law. The Office of Economic Adjustment was founded in 1961 under President Kennedy and Defense Secretary Robert McNamara to soften the local economic effects of base closures and cost reductions. It supported communities through the Base Realignment and Closure rounds and other force reductions, and helped with defence industry cutbacks. It became the Office of Local Defense Community Cooperation on January 1, 2021.

    That office still publishes the annual Defense Spending by State report. Its fiscal year 2023 executive summary estimated Pentagon contract, grant and payroll spending in the 50 states and the District of Columbia at $618.6 billion, about $1,846 per resident, which shows how many local economies have a stake in the defence budget.

    The closed gate of a decommissioned military base with empty barracks behind
    Base closures were a main focus of federal adjustment programmes. Illustration.

    Approaches compared

    ApproachExampleWho leads
    National reconversionUnited States after 1945Firms responding to civilian demand
    Worker alternative planLucas Plan, 1976Shop stewards and employees
    Community adjustmentOffice of Economic Adjustment, from 1961Federal government and local authorities
    State conversion lawConnecticut alternative use committees, from 1994State government, employers and employees
    Adults in a technical training workshop learning to use machine tools
    Retraining is a core part of most conversion plans. Illustration.

    Arguments for and against

    Supporters argue that conversion protects skilled jobs when budgets fall, and that civilian spending creates more jobs per dollar. That claim rests largely on input-output studies from the Political Economy Research Institute at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, such as its 2011 study, which estimated about 11,200 jobs per $1 billion of military spending against 16,800 for clean energy and 26,700 for education.

    Critics and the studies themselves note limits. The same PERI study acknowledges that military jobs tend to pay relatively well. The Lucas Plan shows the other practical obstacle: a workers’ plan depends on management agreeing to adopt it. Wikipedia’s article also notes that conversion efforts were constrained from the late 1990s to about 2010. Our jobs research guide looks at these estimates in more detail.

    Key takeaways

    • Economic conversion means moving labour, capital and technology from military to civilian production.
    • Post-1945 reconversion was the largest example in US history.
    • Seymour Melman popularised advance conversion planning by managers and workers.
    • The 1976 Lucas Plan proposed more than 150 civilian products from an aerospace workforce.
    • The federal Office of Economic Adjustment, renamed in 2021, has handled community adjustment since 1961.

    Common questions

    Is economic conversion the same as disarmament?

    No. Disarmament is about reducing weapons and forces. Economic conversion is about what happens to the workers, factories and communities that produced them. The two are linked, and Melman chaired a commission that combined both words, but conversion can also follow ordinary budget cuts or the end of a weapons programme.

    Has conversion ever worked?

    The clearest success was post-1945 reconversion in the United States, when factories returned to civilian products amid strong consumer demand. Worker-led plans such as the Lucas Plan were influential but not adopted by management. Community adjustment programmes run by the Office of Economic Adjustment have helped many areas after base closures.

    Who was Seymour Melman?

    Seymour Melman (1917–2004) was a professor of industrial engineering and operations research at Columbia University. He wrote Pentagon Capitalism (1970) and other books arguing that military spending weakened civilian industry, and chaired the National Commission for Economic Conversion and Disarmament.

    What is an alternative use committee?

    It is a joint committee of employees and management at a defence plant that plans alternative civilian products and retraining in case military work declines. Connecticut law has required such committees for certain state-assisted defence contractors since 1994.

    What did the Office of Economic Adjustment do?

    Founded in 1961, it helped communities cope with base closures and defence cutbacks through technical and financial assistance, including during the Base Realignment and Closure rounds. It was renamed the Office of Local Defense Community Cooperation on January 1, 2021, and still publishes defence spending data by state.

    How we put this together: we drew the definitions and history from encyclopedia articles on economic conversion, Seymour Melman, the Lucas Plan and the Office of Economic Adjustment, and the figures from the Pentagon’s own state spending report and a PERI study. We present the arguments on both sides without endorsing either. See also world military spending or go to the home page.

    Sources